Hi, hunnicutt77,
I don't fully understand what worked for you here:
The one that didn't work finally did work when I no longer included a textbox which was validating URL and no longer submitted a website starting with "http://".
Can you be more specific?
In the form I was referencing, I was asking for people's websites. It was then validating the URLs, which meant that it was forcing a website to include "http://". For some reason, the contact form wouldn't submit if the website included "http://" in the URL, so I had to remove the validation in order to get it to work and then include a help/description for that item to tell people not to include "http://".
In order to get it to work, I actually had to completely disable multisite and delete the other multisites (for my use they were not actually needed, just useful), and then I had to move the pages to new slugs that hadn't been used while the site was a multisite.
All in all, it was a very frustrating experience, and I'm not sure why it was happening, especially since it was happening for me with several different contact form plugins, not just this one.
I'm sorry, that's probably not super helpful, but that's what "fixed" it for me...